books

Stupidity of The Winners Curse

February 24, 2017
 War runs through Valorian blood, just as art runs through the Herrani. Yet something sets our two heroes aside. They have something else running through their veins, something that doesn’t seem to be present in a great deal of the others. So what is it that makes our two heroes, Arin and Kestrel, so special? Well my dears, the answer is STUPIDITY. I’m not kidding, throughout the book I was almost angry crying at how absolutely stupid the characters were.

True Love

A lot of the problem, I think, stems from how inadequately their infatuation bloomed. There was absolutely no reason for the to love, let alone even like each other! There was barely any contact between the two of them, there were barely any words exchanged that weren’t hostile before they decided that they loved the other. They were enemies one day, and apparently in love the next. To emphasis how ridiculous it was, think about Voldemort and Harry Potter. Remember that scene where Harry gets portkeyed right into the middle of the death eaters, and then tortured by Voldemort? Now imagine Harry declaring his undying love for Voldemort, a day after that – pain still running through his mind and blood still dotting his knees. Yeah, it was like that.

 

It wasn’t even a good hate to love relationship. There was no development, no reason behind any of it! If Kestrel had been kinder to him, I would have understood a little better. If Arin had let her in, rather than shutting her out the entire time and threatening her. Maybe I would have seen reason a little more. But none of those things happened. Instead, we have Kestrel describing him as a savage the whole time, and Arin focusing on his preparation for the war. Not once do they do anything remotely sweet for each other – and don’t tell me they fell in love because of the other person’s brilliant mind. For some reason when Kestrel’s around Arin, she gets a little bit stupid. Why the hell did this happen? Even when they first meet she’s acting foolish. It makes no goddamn sense considering the Valorians are supposed to be warriors, THEY SHOULD ALL BE GODDAMN SMART. Taking into account the Kestrel is supposed to be smarter than the rest of them, she should be a certifiable genius. So either the Valorians are actually extremely stupid and all of their conquering has been a complete fluke, or it’s bad writing. Because if the General decides that his daughter is fit enough to be a military strategist, then she better be goddamn good at what she does.

 

Kestrel’s Stupidity

I mentioned that Kestrel loses her wits around Arin, she does it in a big way. Why the hell would you talk about military plans with someone who is supposed to be your enemy? Why would you offer your theories, and then let them reassure you that it’s all alright? That just doesn’t make any sense to me. Nor, I’m sure, would it make sense to anyone else in the book. Despite favouring Kestrel as smart, everyone else seems a great deal more level headed than her. Sure, Kestrel can tell apart glass from topaz – but she doesn’t think about the consequences. She doesn’t want the Herrani to be punished, yet if the lady selling the fake topaz gets into trouble it will be her fault. It doesn’t take a lot of brains to be able to figure out the glass is fake, just a keen eye. It does take a little more to think things through before saying them, something that Kestrel just doesn’t seem to do, despite being ‘clever’.

 

 
“Except that both events are strange. Oskar had no reason to commit suicide. Even the emperor praised his performance as captain.  His guards admired him.  He seemed happy.”

 

 
Lets talk about what happens when Kestrel gets captured. She threatens to kill herself, which is understandable as it isn’t seen as something bad in Valorian culture, but it is something she could use as leverage against this boy who so obviously likes her. So why did she proclaim it as soon as the bad things start happening, and give him a chance to talk her out of it? Now he knows exactly what her mindset is, and what she’s prepared to do. #stupid

 

Onto the boat, she betrays a whole boat of people who could have fought off the Herrani because she has a brilliant plan. A plan that she then gives up on because she remembered how much she loved it when Arin, her one true love who she’s had five conversations with, kissed her. Once, he’s kissed her once. Does the fact that he’s currently slitting the throats of men that counted on her, matter one bit? Nope. Does it matter that he killed almost all of her friends about an hour ago, poisoned without their knowledge? Nope. Does it even matter that she’s dooming thousands, millions of people to die – just because she wants to continue kissing a boy, who for all she knows, will tear her apart limb from limb after he wins? Nope. All that matters is how she felt when he kissed her. #stupid. Honestly though, what in the seven hells is this quote?!

 

Kestrel listened to the slap of waves against the ship, the cries of struggle and death. She remembered when her heart, so tight, like a scroll, had opened when Arin kissed her. It had unfurled. 

 

Look at that jump, should I care about my people or myself? Yes, those cries of struggle and death are her people. Maybe it was someone who looked after her when she was a child. Maybe it was someone who nursed her back to health, when she was sick and bedridden. Screw that, she thinks, I need to stay loyal to this one guy whose kisses make me happy. Hell, I’m pretty sure that even if her father was on that goddamn ship, she wouldn’t have done a single thing. In fact, her father does cross her mind when she’s been held a ‘political prisoner’ in a luxurious room in Irex’s old home. Yet, she still manages to make excuses about why she shouldn’t be escaping.

 

“Be happy for me,” Arin said. It took her a moment to realise that those words were for the page. 

 

What page is this you ask? Why it’s a letter that Arin is forcing her to write to her father, dooming her people into a longer time of death by poison. Isn’t that just the sweetest thing? Even throughout all of this, she’s still so infatuated with him that she can’t see her own toes through her heart shaped eyes narrowed at him. She believes herself to be so clever, and ruthless. That’s one of the reasons she didn’t want to join the military! She says, because she makes ruthless decisions that are for the better good! Except these decisions she’s making, are idiotic, even for a five year old. A five year old might have some loyalty to their parents, to the people who have looked after them for all their lives. But nope, none of that silly loyalty nonsense from Kestrel. Actually scratch that. Throughout the whole ordeal she’s worried about betraying ARIN, I’m speechless honestly. What is a couple of months compared to a lifetime? Nothing. Although apparently one small kiss, to Kestrel, is worth everything.

 

Arin’s Stupidity


Ha ha ha okay, so I got rid of the book before I could write this part because I’m dumb and forgot that I was writing a post on it. I’m sorry. I do remember some of the things he did though, so I’m going to make a list ( because we all love lists ). There will probably be big spoilers in this part, so feel free to skip over. 

  1. Fell in love with a girl after two conversations
  2. Basically sacrificed the lives of his people, every single one of them, because he wanted her to be happy
  3. Stole a book and got caught, something that could have completely compromised his mission
  4. Killed the leader of the resistance
  5. Gave Kestrel keys to things
  6. Showed one of the people he was supposed to be outsmarting, how smart he was just to prove a point
  7. Like shit, if you’re trying to drag down an empire using stealth – you keep that intelligence to yourself not announce it to the people you’re trying to destroy
  8. Worried more about his ‘true love’ hating him, than dealing with the fact that he was now a huge part of a resistance that could cost people their lives

General Stupidity

Ha ha ha okay, same story as the last point I got rid of the book before I could write this part but there are so so many things that are wrong with this book.
  1. Main character doesn’t give a shit about slaves, except this one who she thinks is cute
  2. There is nothing that talks about how badly the slaves are treated. Slavery is something that should be handled carefully, but that doesn’t mean you mention it a couple of times, but then completely disregard the implications of the word.
  3. The friendship values in this seem fickle. Sure she cares for her friend, but really, is it anything more than superficial? In a great deal of the scenes, the connection seems forced.

So have you read the Winners Curse? If you have, and you loved it – I’m really very sorry. Me and the book just didn’t mesh very well ( as you can tell ). It had huge potential though, so I could definitely see a glint of why people might like it!

follow my:

Don’t forget to subscribe by email please!

You Might Also Like

11 Comments

  • Reply Prabhleen Sachdeva February 25, 2017 at 8:33 am

    I HAVE HEARD SO MUCH ABOUT THIS SERIES LIKE SOOOO MUCH. But reading your thoughts…… I don't know if I want to read this series any more. But it was great to see your face and like watch you talk because I dunno it just seems cool to me lolol. But your nails are on point! #goals
    Prabhleen Booksarelife987

  • Reply Rebecca February 25, 2017 at 4:51 pm

    Aw, I'm sorry you didn't like this one. As with YA, I always suspend disbelief. I'm an old fart and still love YA. I quite liked this series especially because of the politics and caste society world building, and I thought the romance between the two from opposing worlds was sweet and eye opening for both. But, it's definitely not going to work for everyone. AT least you gave it a go!
    Rebecca @ The Portsmouth Review
    Follow me on Bloglovin'

  • Reply Molly's Book Nook February 25, 2017 at 11:39 pm

    hahah omg this review made me laugh. I haven't read this but all I've seen is how amazing this series is. So it's refreshing to see a negative one. I don't know if I can handle so much stupidity. I've read a few books where the girl only thinks about the guy during times of peril. Like…what? Great review!

    Molly @ Molly's Book Nook

  • Reply Molly's Book Nook February 25, 2017 at 11:39 pm

    hahah omg this review made me laugh. I haven't read this but all I've seen is how amazing this series is. So it's refreshing to see a negative one. I don't know if I can handle so much stupidity. I've read a few books where the girl only thinks about the guy during times of peril. Like…what? Great review!

    Molly @ Molly's Book Nook

  • Reply Fleur Books February 27, 2017 at 3:55 am

    Yes! I know it's so confusing as to why they would even be considering the guy, when their life is hanging on the line. It makes absolutely no sense to me. I know for a fact that when adrenaline gets pumping you're not thinking about the meaning of life, but rather your brain forces you to focus on the immediate threat. *sigh* Thank you for reading Molly!

  • Reply Fleur Books February 27, 2017 at 3:57 am

    I was so hyped for this book! I honestly thought that it was going to be great but . . . there were just too many problems to truly enjoy it. Haha I think the youtube videos are going to become a little more permanent now! Thank you for watching 😀

  • Reply Fleur Books February 27, 2017 at 3:58 am

    I completely get how you would like this! I agree, each to their own. Thank you for giving my review a try, even though it wasn't exactly supportive of your personal point of view!

  • Reply Zoe N. March 2, 2017 at 6:08 am

    I'll admit that I absolutely love this series so I'm sad you didn't enjoy it as much as I did, but I can definitely see where you're coming from – you bring up some solid points. Thanks for sharing and, as always, fabulous review! <3

    ~ Zoe @ Stories on Stage

  • Reply Krysta @ Pages Unbound March 4, 2017 at 3:36 am

    I had a lot of problems with this book, many of which you mentioned. Kestrel isn't very smart, as you note, and yet all the other characters act as if she is. I also can't buy that her slave would fall in love with her and that she would fall in love with her slave and then let everyone know about their affair by allowing him to chastise and insult her in public! If she's trying to protect him/their relationship, she shouldn't go around advertising it by allowing him to act “above his station.” She isn't very bright. He isn't either. Yet I'm supposed to buy into the idea that together they can topple a society?

  • Reply Megan May 7, 2017 at 10:14 am

    I'm sad you didn't like this one. I have still to read it. Great review! 🙂

  • Reply Febie Cantutay May 17, 2017 at 6:47 am

    I've been meaning to read this book. Thanks for the review!

  • Leave a Reply to Febie Cantutay Cancel reply

    Follow

    Get the latest posts delivered to your mailbox: